Monday 30 May 2011

Is Life Insurance Halal in India?


First, most people do not know what insurance is. I mean what most people invest in India cannot be called Insurance.

There are 2 types:
  1. Pay premium, get coverage & no returns.
  2. Pay premium, get coverage & get returns at maturity/ intervals.
The 1st one is popularly known as Term Insurance and it is the only real life insurance. The second although not exactly an insurance is called by various names like - ULIP/ ULPP/ Pension Plan/ Endowment, etc.

Basically, insurance is only payment of a premium for an uncertainty. If the uncertainty happens, you get the money assured If everything is fine, you get nothing.

Arguments against insurance:
  1. Challenging Allah with Life: I don't see any challenge in this. We all know we are going to die. What we are doing is that, we pay a small sum, so that in any eventuality, our loved ones are financially secure.
  2. Don't have faith that Allah will help: Faith in Allah doesn't mean just don't do anything. You have to be ready for your death always- and readiness includes your deeds and too some extent planning for your family. If you have earned enough or have sufficient amount of wealth, then there isn't a need for Insurance. It's only the case that you know that if you die today, your family could struggle financially. 
  3. Haram Investments: This issue comes in for those so called insurance which promise a return. Their investments could be categorized into interest and gambling based. As I already said, they are not insurance, hence the question doesn't arise.
  4. Uncertain Contracts/ Gambling: Most contracts/ dealings/ trades involve some degree of uncertainty. This is absolutely fine. It is only those which are 100% uncertain and based entirely on chance that are forbidden. Because in such cases, the chance of loss/ gain is very high and it could leave the losing party utterly sulking with loss.  
    • In pure Insurance, first thing there is certainty that death will occur, so the Insurance company is well aware of the risk; it is only the timing that is uncertain. 
    • Secondly all Insurance companies in India operate on a pan-India basis. They have huge no. of customers. There are statistical tables present that use the science of probability to find out the near-approximate calculations in deciding the premium and the profitability of the company. So there is not really a big gain/loss for any party. Note that most Insurance companies are making huge losses not due to Life Insurance but due to other Insurances. 
    • Thirdly, claim rejections in case of Life Insurance are low.
Recently the Darul Uloom Deoband banned insurance. If you read carefully, you will find that they are talking of interest and gambling aspects. 
Regarding Interest part they do invest in interest bearing securities. However the claim is supposed to be paid from the premium collected. But we can never know for sure if the claim is paid from pooled premium or from interest income. This situation is somewhat similar to salaries paid by companies. You never know if your salary is paid from interest income of the company.
As for the gambling part, I have already explained above, not sure what else they are talking of in gambling. It would be great if someones can throw additional light on that aspect in a clear way with relevant references.
This is the Deoband Fatwa site, I am referring: http://darulifta-deoband.org 
Based on the various responses given for Transactions & Dealing, you can research about it.

8 comments:

  1. Assalamu-alaikkum brother,
    I have two questions:
    1) Is medical insurance in India is Haram? Why( not questioning, bit to know)
    2) Is Life insurance in India is Haram? Why
    I could not conclude these two from your post, that's why I am asking this question.
    Abdu

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Walakum assalam,
      I have updated the last section of this article to answer your question giving more details; however I cannot give any direct answer.
      Both medical and term insurance are grey areas...they maybe/ may not be halal.

      Delete
  2. One thing is not good regarding even pure insurance is that whatever coverage one get is from others money.

    ReplyDelete
  3. ULIP contain a part of premium for mortalitiy charges , so it has that part so we should consult ULMA E IQRAM for this too

    ReplyDelete
  4. Darul Uloom Deoband banned insurance, because its like gamble, if you die copany will loose money or if you dont die then you will loose money. same ting happens in gamble, who will get the money it fully depends on coincidence.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Insurance companies invest our money in debt instruments, shariah and non shariah complaint equity scripts. Therefore this is purely Haraam.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Is Investing at pure stock fund is halaal or haraam

    ReplyDelete
  7. investment in TATA AIA ULIP - o Super Select Equity Fund having Benchmark NIFTY 500 Shariyah - 100% is valid or Haram. Please advise.

    ReplyDelete